Well if he loves her a lot then he should steal it. I think it's better to sacrifice your freedom for a life.
WHOOO! FIRST COMMMENT!
Oops. Sorry I didn't even answer true question. Heinz should steal the drug, but not go to jail because that would be unfair.
I believe that Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail for it. In doing so he would be saving his wife's life while taking a sacrifice.
I think he should steal the drug and not go to jail because he would be able to give the drug to his girl friend, and not have to have his girl friend bail him out hencforth, making him lose his girl friend.
I disagree with Blake. I think he should go to jail for stealing the drug because it is only fair that he does, after commiting a crime.
I think that if he loves her enough, he will do whatever he needs to do. He should steal the drug and go to jail.
I agree he should steal it because it's someone he loves and would rather get to see her than see her grave. That would make him unselfish .
3rd person!!!!!!! :D "Treasure chest is MINE!
By the way Kayla, I said the treasure chest is kine because: 1st is the worst, 2nd is the best, 3rd is the one with the treasure chest! :D
Ok at first I said steal the drug and don't go to prison because that is unfair. (Post-conventional). But, then I realized the company spent a lot of money making the drug, and didn't want to go bankrupt. So he should take the drug and go to jail. (Conventional). I say that because you think this is unfair? That could give robbers an excuse, because they could say "no bank account", "they would not give me money" "im out of money and need food"
Kinda unlogical, but you get my point. I change my answer I THINK. I may come back later and change it back. :D :P
I agree with Emily Stone that they spent an interminable and difficult time to make the medication. I also believe that if he really loves his wife, he can steal the drug. I think he can't be excused for stealing the drug because the company made a very expensive drug and he can't afford it. So, I think that Heinz needs to steal the medication and go to jail.
I agree with Felix and Emily I think the guy should steal the drug because, the girl will be able to live and when he goes to prison, him and his wife will have enough time to pay off what he did. I also think it's unfair what the C.E.O. did because, they think there all that, but from them being so greedy they don't know that some people don't have that kind of money.
I think that he should steal the drugs but not go to jail because once you think about it the girl will get to live her life free while he rots in jail. Then again she also had something to do with and so if he go she should go.
I have to disagree with Xavier. If he is willing to risk being put in jail by stealing he should face the punishment that comes with it. I also disagree that you said the wife should go to. Guarantied the wife did have cancer but she didn't/ won't be the one stealing the drug
Soory I didn't mean to spell your name wrong. X'Zavier
Since the company spent a lot of money and a difficult time making the drug, I think that Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail. He might be saving his wife in all, but you should still get punished for your actions.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug and go to prison for it. I think it is unfair for the C.E.O to do that to him when his wife is dying. I think that he should go to prison too becuse he did steal a drug and it is a law not to steal.
I believe that Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail. Even though stealing is against the law, sometimes you have to sacrifice things for the person(people) you love,
I agree with you Jemiah, because sometimes for the people you love, you have to make sacrifices, and if Heinz didn't love her, then he wouldn't of done anything to try and save his wife's life.
I would let her die because other people have to do the same thing no need to steal it you wil get caught and wont get it to her in time and you will go to jail...
I agree with Isaiah because you shouldn't break the law just to save somebody you love. If you did break the law to get the drug, there's no way you would get away with it anyway, so if he stole the drug, his wife would be alive, but he wouldn't even get to see her because he would be in prison.
I think Heinz should steal the drug and except any prison sencents. I know its wrong that the C.E.O made the drug more money but he is stealing and that is breaking a law so yes i understand why he would do that but, its still breaking the law.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug from the company, but then accept the consequence and go to jail. If Heinz really loved his wife, he would steal the drug. Then again, all of the company"s hard work has gone to nothing. It is not their fault that Heinz's wife is sick. Even though it was for a good cause, Heinz still broke the law. Therefore, Heinz needs to pay his time in prision to repay the company.
What I think that he should do is steal the drug and go to jail. I think this because if he doesn't get the drug then his wife will die.Then if she dies he might die and yea but if he gets the drug and goes to jail he will save her life. He will accualy be risking his freedom but if he really loves her then he will risk his freedom for her. If he steals the drug he does need to go to jail because it is against the law to steal it would not be fair if he could just steal and not go to jail.If u could steal and not go to jail everyone would stesl everything. :D
I think that he should steal the drug and take the jail sentence because he is saving her life. Even though it may seem unfair that the drug is so high, and Mr.Heniz stole the drug, he still needs to go to jail. Thats just how life works, you have to pay a price to get what you want.
I think that he should steal the drug and take the jail sentence because he is saving her life. Even though it may seem unfair that the drug is so high, and Mr.Heniz stole the drug, he still needs to go to jail. Thats just how life works, you have to pay a price to get what you want. ~<3
I agree with Bree. I think he should steal the drug and go to jail. It wouldn't be fair to th CEO if he didn't get punished(even though the CEO is a big jerk).
Sorry for the spelling error! Please don't take points off Mr.Herr!
I agree with Bree. I think he should steal the drug and go to jail. It wouldn't be fair to the CEO if he didn't get punished(even though the CEO is a big jerk).
I believe that Mr. Heinz should steal the drug for his wife and accept the consequence of going to prison. He knows what will come out of the crime he committed, but sometimes people do crazy things to protect the person they love.
I think Mr.Heinz should still the drug because it would save his wife's life. Then he should go to jail knowing that without the drug his wife would have died.
If he really loves her he should steal the drug and accept any prison sentence.If I were him i would sacrifice anything to save the person that I love.
Well in my honest opinion, I believe that he should steal the drugs also because he would be saving his wife's life. I understand he would be going to jail, but its for a good cause and that cause is saving his wife's life.
I also believe that Heinz should steal the drug to save his wife's life and accept whatever prison sentence that he deserves. He will have to have to go to jail, but at least his wife's life will be saved and when he gets out of prison he will be able to see her again. I would risk anything for the person that I love to live or for them to be happy.
So, Anyse, let me get this straight; save a life through stealing, and suffer the consequences of the act. Sounds admirable, right? Not so fast! What of the tone that's being set here? What of the precedence being set that stealing is okay? What if more husbands than just Heinz were in this dilemma? Should they also steal the drug? And if so, wouldn't theft run quite rampant and stealing become the norm? And furthermore, what about the destruction of livelihood brought about by stealing from someone (or some company) that's trying to make a product so as to help humanity while also providing an income to its employees? If the drug is to be stolen, wouldn't Heinz be saving a life at the expense of damaging another? I mean those who develop and sell the drug have a right to make a living from it, right? And if they can't make a living because of theft, don't they in turn become the victims too? Anyse, please consider the well-being of more who might be involved in this situation.
I agree with you alot.I disagree because stealing is a bad thing to do.I agree with you because a person will do everything with all their might to save a love one.Mr.Heinz should steal the drug for his wife.He sould becasue he told the man that he has half but he will pay the rest off.If he goes to jail will the money he has save for the drug he sould use to get out.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug so that his wife can live, but take any prison sentance that he needs. It is better to have the person you love during visiting hours then not at all.
I think Mr. hernz should had worked for money to by a drug for his wife instead of stealing drugs and causing him to stay in jail for lots of years, also not seeing her.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug and save his wife and go to jail for it. His wife would be safe and as soon as he gets out of jail they can live together.
but since they cant afford the drug what makes you think they can afford to bail him out of jail???
I think he should steal the medicine and take the consequences. I'm not saying that stealing is okay, but I'd rather do that than just let her die.
I mean that's the one that seems most reasonable out of the three.
I completly agree with you Morgan!
I think that Heinz should probably steal the drug and go to jail for it because he really loved his wife but he was willing to break the rules to save her so he could have at least been prepared for the consequences. Besides the clip never said how long he would be in prison so he could be on probation and he could see her every once in a while or something. But I think he would have been wise enough to know that to save his wife's life he would also have to suffer the consequenses. :)
In my opinion I believe that Heinz should steal the drug and go to prison for it. My explanation would rather back me up, because if Heinz steals the drug and does not go to prison for it, it will be unfair for others who have loved ones that have cancer, that steal the drug and end up going to prison for it. If Heinz truly does love his wife he should do whatever it takes. I would think that Mr. Heinz would appreciate what Heinz did for her. He risked his life because who knows he could have been killed by the cops. I would also like to go back onto what Brittney Yongo said and that was "I think he would have been wise enough to know that to save his wife's life he would also have to suffer the consequences." So that is why I believe that Heinz should steal the drug but go to prison for his action.
I believe that Heinz should steal the drug and then accept the punishment. Although I do agree that going to jail is unfair, I don`t think that the court would be sympathetic. To them, stealing is stealing. No matter why they did it or not. It would be easier to just save his wife and accept the punishment. To me, this is the most reasonable answer.
At first I thought Heinz should steal the drug and not go to prison because it was unfair what the C.E.O did, but then I realized that they did invest a lot of time and hard work into making the drug. I still think it is unfair because he raised half the money and they didn't even spend that much on the drug when they made it so I think they should have given it to him for half price. I still think he should steal the drug to save his wife but now I think he should go to prison. At least he will get to see his wife again and not have to watch them bury her because he didn't take the chance to save his wife's life and have that guilt on him (even though it wasn't his fault). So I think he should steal the drug and go to jail.
Like what most everyone saidI think that Heinz should steal the drug and except the consequences.
*sorry said I not saidI
I believe in my opinion that Heinz should steal the drug and accept any punishments. I think that in this case stealing should be done, because someone is dying slowly and their life is on the line. In other cases, I would say stealing is a big NO, because you just steal for yourself and you're not helping others with it. Even though the CEO would not be caring and sell the drug for less, I think Heinz should still steal it, even though it isn't a good thing, and help the dying person.
He should go get some other person to help his wife
I Think that Herinz should steal the drug and get whateever punishment he gets. I dont think its right for the CEO to know that his wife is dying and still not lower the price at least for a few hundred.
I think Heinz should not steal the drug because he would be breaking the law and if he did his, wife would be heart broken to not see her husband
If I was in Heinz situation I would steal the drug. The reason why is because if I really loved my wife I would do anything for her. Stealing is not okay but if love was involved then would do anything.
I believe that Heinz should steal the drug,even though stealing is against the law, and then go to jail. I think that it is better to give away your freedom and save the person you love then to watch them die. He should go to jail afterwards because he did steal the drug and beak the law. Heinz not going to jail would be the unfair thing, not him keeping his freedom as it suggests in the video.
I if he loves her he should steal the drug. but not go to jail he should tell why because he did it to.keep her
I think Heinz should steal the drug and accept any prison sentence because it would be making a sacrifice for the one you love. Yes It's not fair that the CEO didn't let him pay for what he has now and pay for the rest later but It's still considered stealing and stealing is against the law.
I believe that the right thing for Heinz to do would be to steal the drug and face the consequence of going to jail. If Heinz really loved his wife he would steal the drug to keep her alive. This shows his true love for his wife. Heinz going to jail is not the correct reaction of stealing the drug, because he is saving the life of his wife. Having this thought does not change the fact that I think that Heinz should go to jail for stealing because yes, in general stealing is wrong. So, my final answer would be for Heinz to steal the drug to save his wife's life and face the consequence of going to jail.
I completely agree with Ericka. Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail as his consequence. If he truly loves his wife, he would steal the drug. He should go to jail because that's the fair thing to do. The company spent a great amount of money and research into this drug and for Heinz to steal it would only mean a punishment for him. Although he will have to go to jail, his wife will be alive. After he is released from jail, he and his wife can live happily together and go on with their lives.
I believe that Heinz should do nothing and let her die. Stealing is wrong and should not be done under any circumstance. If he had stolen the drug, and gone off to prison his wife would be alone and nothing would have been accomplished. I also think that if he was to steal the drug and not be punished would be unfair. He stole, and therefore has done wrong.
Ethan, I tend to disagree with you here. Heinz tried to go through the proper channels to legally get the drug -- those channels failed him. As a last resort, stealing for the sake of preserving life is acceptable. So Heinz's act was, to me, permissable. In fact, I would go so far as to suggest that he not receive the punishment of prison. Companies that mark up the prices of products that serve the betterment of society should relinquish their profit-grubbing hold on the middle and lower classes of society. These developers of helpful technology should be satisfied with helping to preserve and enhance our civil society -- not to drive them toward illegal actions (like stealing) for trying to save the lives of those they love. So, Ethan, I don't believe Heinz, with his theft, is the real criminal here. I believe that the idea of reckless capitalism should be held more responsible.
I believe that Heinz should steal the drug and still go to jail. It might be ideal for him to steal the drug and not go to jail, but it's not right. If he truly and completely loves his wife he would be willing to sacrifice his own freedom to save and protect her.
If I were Heinz, I would steal the drug and accept the punishment. The reason is that he probably loves his wife a lot. I would do anything to save my wife. I would accept any punishment as long as the wife is safe and healthy.
If I were the guy I would steal the drug and go to jail. If you love your wife you would do anything for her.
If I were the guy I would steal the drug and go to jail. If you love your wife you would do anything for her. The guy should steal the drug and go to jail he would probably accept any punishment as long as his wife is alive.
Hienz shouldnt steel the drug because now your wife is i a better place but both of u would win no jail and a happy life in the clouds.
In my own personal opinion I think Heinz should steal the drug so that he may save his wife’s life for if you think about it he is doing this so that he may save another’s life, more importantly his wife’s. The Judge should be able to accept the reality that he is doing it for a good cause not that he is doing it just because he feels like. Heinz should steal the drug for inhumane to punish him for saving another’s life.
I think Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail for it because it would be unfair to other people who had already paid the full amount.Stealing the drug and not going to jail would be great right, you have your wife you got the drug and your free right wrong your going to have all that except for the freedom you will be hunted down be whatever law enforcement they had at the time and you would have a big knot of guilt in your stomach because your a fugutive. If you don't steal the drug and let your wife die I couldn't live with the sadness of knowing that you could have saved your wives life. Like other people before me who have said that quote- on-quote''you would do any thing for your wife if you loved her. Your wife goes before your life.I could take a bullet for my wife.''All those quotes show that those husbands would do anything for there wives. Refering to Mr. Herr's 1st comment where if there are many people in that situationand they all steal the drug the government(if they have a good one) should notice how the drug is getting stolen because the price is to high the CEO should lower the price because inless he is stubborn I think he would accept a lower price than going out of buisness.
The video stated that Heinz should steal the drug and not go to prison as that would be unfair. I on the other hand believe that Heinz should steal the drug without worrying about what happens to him. His love for his wife should be so great that he is willing to sacrifice any freedom. I do believe tat this dilemma was unfair and he shouldn't have to do time, but like I said, he should not worry about what happens to him. "A sacrifice is being willing to give up your life of freedom for a life of longevity"
Scratch that. After reviewing the dilemma one more time, I realized that even though it would save his wife, the morals are all wrong. It is never right to steal. The guilt brought with it and the fact the company is losing money with the potential of hurting it's business, is not right.
I think Heinz should still it and not go to jail, because the person who made the formula want to help people. How are they helping people if the formula is their whole life savings they just gonna let the person die
I think Heinz should steal the drug and suffer any consequences.It's wrong for that man to charge more than it's actual price.That one formula can change a life or death situation. If Heinz loved his wife truly he would do any thing for her,no matter what consequences he has to suffer.
i think that heinz should have stole the drug and gave it to her and take eney prision charge because if he really loves her and he want her to stay alive and not die. and so i would have taken the drug and taken eney prision charge.
I think that Heinz should steal the medicine to save her wife and take what ever consequences come with the crime. Even though stealing is bad, I think it's better to keep a life then loose a life. If it were me, I would steal it for the person I loved.
I meant his wife not her wife..(:
I agree with everybody that said he should steal and go to jail for his Girl. Letting her die would be depressing. Any good Husband would probably do the same. IT JUST MAKES SENSE MAN!
(how come nobody thought he should steal and not go to jail)
Heinz should steal the drug and accept the consequence. I think that because if he didn't accept the consequence then he might be living with guilt that he stole something for the rest of his life even though he might be able to be with his wife. If he does the consequence then he'll still be able to see his wife (maybe not that often but still). If I was him then I would do that because I'd rather barely see the person I love rather than letting them die and never being able to see them ever again.
Contrary to popular belief, I think that Heinz should not steal the drug. I know that his wife would die, but if he steals the drug, the penalty for stealing a drug that rare would most likely be prison for life. That would be just like his wife dying because he would never be able to see her again anyways. Also, stealing is never a good thing to do, and as a result of Heinz stealing the drug the company will lose money. I just think that it would be better for Heinz to accept the fact that his wife is going to die than to go and steal.
I agree with Libby. Heinz shouldn't steal the drug. He has already loved his wife long enough and it's even better to know that his wife will be in a better place. Plus Heinz would still be able to visit her almost every day, he would never have to think she was doing something wrong, and he would always have her in his heart so she and Heinz could live for ever. Love never dies in my opinion.
I believe that Mr. Heinz should steal the medicine and take the consequences, I mean I know stealing isn't good but say someone you loved was dying would you steal the medicine she/he needs or would you let the person die? In my opinion Mr. Heinz did a good thing by stealing the medicine and accepting the consequences, it showed that Mr. Heinz really loved his wife and he didn't want to see her die.
He should steal the medicine to save his wife and suffer the consequences. I'm sure that if Heinz referenced the judges spouse and what they would do for them, his punishment wouldn't be as severe and the C.E.O would be in trouble for raising the cost.
I think that he should take the drug, because he loves his wife so he will try to save her evan if it means he has to go to gail. In this situition he should not go to gail.
I think there are two sides to this story. Side one he should steal the drug and let his wife visit him in jail and have his wife live .I mean hes got to get out one day beacause for stealing i depends how much u steal but since you steal a expencive drug he would probly get rom three to four months in jail. Hes lucky that he doesnt go to prison fpr this so you no what there is only one side to this story but thats my opinion. He can do what he wants thats his decision. People can persuad you all there life but its you that will make the dicision to follow them or not.
I think that he should go to jail because even though he couldn't afford the medicine, if all thief's pretended that they were poor and got away with stealing then everybody would do it.But i also cant decide about the fact that the seller sold it to Heinz for 10 times more than the actual price. :())) :()))
LASTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT ONEEEEEEEE!!!!!!! WOOH! WOOH! :& %) :~) IM AWESOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMEEEEEE :))))))))))) <3 <3 <3 <3
I think Heinz should steal the drug and take his punishment because we know stealing is against the law but his wife is dying and she needs the drug. This is what I would do.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug to save his wife and accept the consequences. Even though he had a good reason to steal the drug, he would probably be sent to jail for stealing. If he truly loves his wife, then he would steal the drug because at least he would know his wife is ok even if he recieves punishment for his actions. =)
If I were in the same situation as Heinz, I would steal the drug and go to jail. I would want my loved one to live, and if I truly cared about their health I would be satisfied with knowing that they would survive. So I think if Heinz really cared about his wife he would rather go to jail than let her die.
I think that Heinz should steal the drug risking the chance of gong to jail. If you truly love someone and car about that peron then you will risk a lot to go see her and when she gets better than she will bail you out of jail or at least come see you whenever she can
I think Hienz should not steal the drug because there is no use you every one is going to die eventually. Yes you can try its ok to try but i am just saying every one will die eventually. to me i would try but keep in mine every is going to die
I think that Heinz should steal the drug from the company. I think that because it isn't right for the company not to sell it to save Heinzs wife. also, I think he shouldn't go to jail if he steals it because he was saving another human beings life. Therefore he shouldn't go to jail.
I think that he should steel the drug like many others think.
I think that Hines should seal the drug because the company was charging to much for the drug and it was not available to the average person. There is a saying that i strongly believe in and its " the needs of the many out weigh the needs of the few". if Hines really lovers her he should steal the drug and not go to prison.
I think Heinz should steal the drug and go to jail. I think this for a few reasons...
First although controversial I think he should still have to go to jail for stealing even if its "technically" unfair. It's not Heinz property to take, but its understandable for saving his wives life.
Secondly I think he should steal the drug anyway even if it means going to jail. If he loves his wife enough, he would do anything for her even if it means a life sentence from a greedy C.E.O.
Third I don' t think Heinz should feel bad for stealing the medicine, the C.E.O should feel bad for not saving someones life like that, not Heinz.
Finally to sum it up I think He should steal it and face the price of jail. Although It may be unfair for someone to be greedy with things like that, you can't make them share there wealth (or in this case medicine).
I think he should steal the drug and accept the punishment ,because I believe everything comes at a price .To save his wife he has to except a punishment and steal.I guess it's unfair to steal with the opposing side losing money.but nothing is more valueable than life.
Are you closed?
Ok just like everybody else I would steel the drug. Even though its wrong its the women I love. But i think if they found out and i went to jail they would know my wife consumed it and im pretty sure if the people who made the drug found out who consumed it they would make her pay the company back. With something to think about this is Andrew Bino make it a great day or not. That choice is yours go griffins
I think that Heinz should not steal the drug. It is unmoral to steal, no matter the situation. If he stole the drugs and his wife ended up getting better, he would still have to suffer the consequences of his actions and go to jail, but then his wife would be left alone. People die from sickness all the time, it's life. If everyone stole things because they thought their reason was just then our whole world would be corrupt. That's just my opinion, I think that he should follow the law and not steal the drug.
Just like everyone else i think that Hienz should steal the drug and go to jail because he will still get to have his wife alive even though he is in jail. I think that any man who truly loves his wife will definatly risk there life to saver her's.
I think Heinz should steal the drug to save his wife and not go to jail because it is unfair to make a drug that is to expensive for the general public and also because seeing that Heinz didn't have the money but pleaded to sell it for half price, the drug seller should have made an exception.
I think Heinz should steal the drug even though he might be put in jail. The wife would have already consumed the drug and Heinz would be considered a for real man. That's why I think he should still the drugiesss. (:
I think Heinz should not steal the drug because he would be breaking the law
I think that Heinz should steal the drug and have the company exposed for selling the drug at an unfair cost, therefore staying out of prison.
I agree with Gregory. Heinz should steal the drug then expose the company for being unfair
As your English teacher, I support both communication and collaboration. Furthermore, since opinions are a most valued freedom, let's express them thoughtfully and respectfully.